Listening to Persimmon give his response, Oberon simply stood there and let the smoke from his cigar dissipate into the air. At least it was somewhat thought out he thought as Persimmon finished stating his reasons. Taking a puff from his cigar, he continued to listen as Sherwood tried to state that it wasn't hopeless. Well...he's got a point... he thought, taking another puff as he let the silence hang in the air for a moment. Taking a deep breath, he looked first at Sherwood and then towards Argent and Noctis before giving his attention to Persimmon.
"You've made some valid points, Persimmon." Oberon stated, acknowledging the student briefly. "You're right in saying that there could have been people nearby and that you could've gone and gotten help. You're right in saying that there was no way to let the rest of your team know your intentions without letting the enemy know. Yes, you are right on those aspects." Letting those comments sit for a moment, Oberon looked at the others again before setting his gaze on Persimmon again over his burning cigar. "However, you did not answer my question. I did not ask you why you retreated unannounced. I asked why you knowingly went against your team captain's order and left your team to die? " Walking over to where Noctis and Suntalia were sitting, Oberon gestured to him. "You're right in saying that you could've gone and gotten help. However, given how long the fight lasted and when you retreated, every single one of your comrades would have been dead long before you would've returned." Walking back over to where Persimmon was standing, Oberon gave the young lad a stern gaze through the smoke in the air. "You see, Persimmon. The problem here isn't simply that you deserted your teammates. No, no, no. The real problem is that you're just a coward who knew that the fight would end like this so you decided that it would be better to save your own skin by leaving your comrades behind to die." Moving closer so that his face was mere inches away from Persimmons, Oberon gave the young student a hard, penetrating gaze with his brown eyes. "And their deaths will be on your hands and conscience for the rest of your life." he said quietly, not blinking once as he continued to look straight into Persimmon's eyes.
After a moment, Oberon moved away from to address everyone standing before him. "I will say this, though. Being a coward is not necessarily a bad thing. Better a living coward than a dead hero, right?" he said, looking over at Persimmon before gazing at the others again. "Persimmon did choose the right option in the end. Retreating would've meant that most, if not all of you, would've made it out of there alive or at least within closer proximity of getting help." Looking over at Persimmon once more again, Oberon continued. "Let this be a learning lesson for you, Persimmon: you show to have decent judgment in assessing a fight as well as a good head for common sense. Use it to your advantage by discussing plans with the rest of your teammates, even if it means contradicting and going against them. For one simple comment can change a deadly situation into a more advantageous circumstance."
Turning his attention over to Sherwood, Oberon gave the young man a hard, penetrating look. "Let this also be a learning lesson for you Sherwood. Being the leader of the team means that the lives of your teammates are in your hands. That means that the decisions and plans you make will ultimately decide if they live or die. With that in mind, be ready to lay out your plans, but also be willing to listen to your teammates and ask for their opinions on the matter. Use this fight as a lesson to build you into a better leader, comrade and friend to the others here."
Taking another puff, he let the smoke linger in the air briefly before blowing it away. "Lastly, I will say this to all of you: look at each member here beside you. They are your comrades in arms and your family during the duration of your stay here at Beacon. Just as you want to protect your family from dying, treat each other as your brother and be ready to do whatever it takes to keep each other alive. You have the potential to become a great team here at Beacon, but it will only go so far as to how well you trust and can rely on each other. Let this be a stepping stone in the direction of making the four of you into one of the greatest teams that Beacon has seen."
Letting his words echo somewhat through the Arena, Oberon turned his attention to Suntalia and Savas. "As their upperclassmen, perhaps you'd like to add something?" he inquired?
Hearing Oberon bear down upon the other students, Suntalia tried her best to focus on what was before her than on what was going on over there. Hearing Persimmon's remarks about the fight had left a foul taste in her mouth, but she couldn't quite go against his judgment. He had decided to fulfill the mission and at least try to go and get help so she could understand why he made the decision. However, Obi made a lot of valid points and only validated why Suntalia didn't quite agree with Persimmon. Using the tweezers to slowly dislodge the glass from Noctis' back, she did it as gently as she could so as to not have any of it break inside. "Once I remove the glass, your aura should be able to heal the wounds. Just be still a little bit more" she said in a motherly sort of tone.
Upon hearing Oberon ask if she had anything else to say, she simply shook her head before focusing on her work. "You guys did good! I had a lot of fun!" she exclaimed happily, giving each of them a dimpled smile. "If it makes you guys feel better, Obi did the same thing to the team I'm on and we didn't even last nearly as long!" she said, laughing lightly. "OOOH! How about we do dinner tonight? My treat!" she inquired, darting a glance at each person quickly. "This includes you too, Vashie! Obi, you're welcome to join if you want." she added before going back to her work as she continued to pull more glass out.
As Persimmon gave his reasons for why he left the fight, Savas couldn't help but feel a sense of anger build up within him. Even as Oberon began to explain everything, it did little to stop what was going through his head. Memories of Vigdus began flashing through his mind: of days spent sparring against each other to see who was better to sitting next to each other laughing as they had both gotten accepted to Beacon. Even the years at Beacon were flooded with memories from the day that Vigdus was chosen to be the leader to nights where they would all be studying together. All those memories came crashing through as they hit the pinnacle of the moment Vigdus was slashed to death before his very eyes.
Trying to calm himself down, Savas tried to suppress the memories, but was unsuccessful as he heard one name echo through his mind...
...Auburn....
Immediately. his mind went to work as he remembered the day he was first paired up with her as well as days spent helping train her to become a better warrior in exchange to her helping him with his studies. The warmth of her smile to the tears of joy she cried the day he confessed his love to her. Every memory of her flashed quickly through his mind as Oberon continued to address team ASPN: the warm feeling of her head resting against his arm as they watched the sunset over the Emerald Forest, the sweet smell of her just washed hair to the soft caresses of her hand against his cheek that was enough to make him face an entire army of Grimm. As each memory played through, it came to an end as he pictured her tear-streaked face as he watched her get eaten alive before his very eyes.
As the memories faded, Savas came to the realization that Oberon had asked if either Suntalia or himself had anything to add. Hearing Suntalia try and uplift the mood, Savas clenched his fists tightly, causing his metaled gauntlets to creak slightly. Walking over to where Persimmon was standing, Savas simply stared down at the first year. Suppressing every desire to slam the boy into the ground, Savas simply unclenched his fist and took a breath. "If you only care about yourself, then you will never truly live" he said quietly, his voice rumbling like a volcano about to erupt as he glared down at Persimmon. Turning around, he walked back to where Oberon stood. "Ngggrh...that is all" he said, resuming to stand like a lone tower against the waves of hell that came from the world.